Good writing, with a strong point and with life oozing out.

Quid Pro Quo?

February 21, 2006

“If God is dead, then all is permitted.” So said Dostoyevsky. “If you knew for sure that God did not exist, would you live your life any differently?” So queried the ethics prof in class tonight.

Which led to a great discussion as we concluded our coverage of religious ethics (Christianity, atheism, Navajo, Islam, and Buddhism). Are our religious ethics based on rewards and punishment? Heaven and hell? Is our motivation extrinsic, or intrinsic? Is our student who is sure that God does not exist, but who is determined to act ethically regardless, the most ethical one among us?

Posted in:

2 Responses to “Quid Pro Quo?”

  1. dave stavlund says:

    Mike:

    Obviously a DEEP question but we know God is alive. I’m reminded of a Spring day in a fishing boat in IOWA when you said “How could anyone doubt we were created and blessed with the beauty of nature and life.”

  2. dave stavlund says:

    Mike:

    Obviously a DEEP question but we know God is alive. I’m reminded of a Spring day in a fishing boat in IOWA when you said “How could anyone doubt we were created and blessed with the beauty of nature and life.”

Leave a Reply